Chapter 4: Separation from Routine and Habit

Patchett’s fourth chapter of Bel Canto describes the hostages’ situation approximately two weeks into the ordeal. Characters begin to exhibit intensified signs of distress while longing to return to the daily routine that they had previously followed in their planned and structured lives. Here I’ll further detail examples of such behavior in an attempt to better understand not only the current mood of the hostages, but also to predict their future interactions.

The power of habit is first demonstrated as early in the novel as Chapter 2, where Fyodorov – a Russian who does not even speak the language of the terrorists – challenges them by giving in to the force of habit and smoking a cigarette. Shortly after lighting his cigarette, “General Benjamin snap[s] his fingers and one of the minions rush[es] forward to take Fyoforov’s cigarette away, but [he] only inhale[s].” “‘Just try,’ he [says] to the soldier in Russian.” In this scenario, the force of habit is so strong that a hostage is willing to die just to satisfy his urges with a smoke one last time. A key piece to remember here is that this happened in Chapter 2 – well before the terrorists lightened up and began letting the hostages casually relax amongst each other and freely dwell about the house. How could the hostage display such courage in a situation as backwards as this one?

According to author Elizabeth Wright of the University of Alabama at Birmingham, “the process of addiction involves an overwhelming motivation to seek out the addictive substance in spite of negative consequences, a loss of the ability to control intake of the substance, and the development of a negative mental and physical state when access to the substance is prohibited” [1]. In other words, Fyodorov simply could not have let himself pass up a smoke – he needed to smoke, and there was no stopping him – not even when his own life was put in danger. Compulsive behaviors and satisfying urges triggers the brain’s “reward system” [1]. “Neuroplasticity and changes in dopamine concentrations in these areas are… responsible for the behaviors associated with addiction.” It is this physical barrier that makes habits and addictions so difficult – and oftentimes impossible – to break.

The terrorists pull the hostages from their daily lives and in doing so also interrupt their daily routines and schedules. Although this doesn’t seem particularly harmful, it is in fact the reason for the accompanist’s death in Chapter 3; without his scheduled intake of insulin he is unable to live. Although the routines of the other characters might not be life-threatening, they certainly are prevalent enough to cause some discomfort when absent. In other words, falling out of rhythm away from older habit is certainly no “vacation,” as Roxanne Coss puts it. Other characters particularly in Chapter 4 begin to show ever-rising levels of stress as the hostage situation pulls into its second week. One possible significant contribution to this stress is falling out of practice of daily routine and habit.

Nansei’s Vice Presodent Tetsuya Kato plays Ruben’s borrowed Steinway piano after Roxanne Coss is determined to exercise her opera voice once again. As Kato begins to play he notices “how strange his fingers felt after two weeks of not playing, as if the skin he wore now was entirely new.” Although Kato is only slightly out of practice, he is still able to play without much trouble. And when he does play, he closes his eyes so that he can “imagine [he] is home, playing his own piano” while “his wife [is] asleep” and “his children, two unmarried sons [are] still living with them.” Kato earns a psychological reward similar to that which Fyodorov experiences in Chapter 2. And although her talent is not demonstrated in this chapter, Roxanne Coss will likely experience some degree of difficulty singing for at least the first few notes she hits.

According to author Leslie Kane of Breaking Bad Habits, “unlearning a habit that you’ve been practicing for 10 or 20 years demands effort and vigilance. Habits are behaviors you’ve repeated so often, you now do them on autopilot. They’ve become part of your comfortable routine, and they often help you alleviate stress” [2]. The hostages now out of touch with their social lives and routines, in summary, are more than likely to experience some degree of stress and discomfort in this new environment. Local contractor Oscar Mendoza begins to believe the hostages will end up dead – he finds positive thinking increasingly difficult and begins to lose hope. This foreshadows how the hostages might behave in future chapters: increasing annoyance, loss of hope, and further separation from reality.

In conclusion, the characters in Patchett’s fourth chapter are behaving approximately as expected given they’ve been separated from the routine and habit of their normal lives. Characters begin to stress and lose hope while losing sight of returning to their outside lives; to return would solve the problem, though that solution at this point begins to seem unlikely from the hostages’ perspectives. These behaviors foreshadow a loss in hope as they remain separated from their families, jobs, and social lives.

Works Cited




One thought on “Chapter 4: Separation from Routine and Habit

  1. bsejdiu942 says:

    Hey Colin,

    I find your research on habits to be quite interesting. You tied together multiple situations that occurred at several points throughout the book. I’m sure that this will arise in prevalence as the story goes on, being that he very situation they are in forces them to obey their captors. For continued research, you could perhaps focus on what is the process that leads to these habits, what environmental factors happen to contribute towards them? How can an individual with a habit, or a severe addiction perhaps, overcome their problem? What research is being done to help individuals on the road to recovery? A thought that struck close to home is how an individual can be shown to have an actual addiction. I have a family member who happens to have a severe gaming addiction, to the extent where all his free time goes towards playing video games. Yet when I bring up the fact that this is so, he says he doesn’t have a problem with it, and gets extremely defensive and aggressive when he doesn’t get to game. When looking up family members comments on other loved one’s addictions, such as alcoholism, the same thing occurs. The afflicted individual has no idea it is happening, or in some cases completely refuses and goes into denial. Getting help is one of the first steps, so I wonder if there is some sort of procedure or research towards helping people realize this in some way.

    I wonder if you could also focus on a smaller scale of rehabilitation treatment in South America, how many cases are dealt with successfully. Then, comparing this to a first one nation and see if anything interesting pops up? Another idea that came up is the stigmatism that occurs when people hear someone has an addiction, especially a drug addiction. There are so many people I know that when they hear this, they look down upon an individual. You can study the social aspect of this, and why people only see an addiction rather than a human being who needs help?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s